Sakya Chokden

Content sourced from Wikipedia, licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Serdok Penchen Shakya Chokden (1428–1507) was a leading thinker of the Sakya school in Tibetan Buddhism. He studied with Rongtön Shecha Kunrig and other scholars and also received teachings from Kagyu lineages. His seat was the Thubten Serdogchen monastery in southern Shigatse.

Chokden challenged Sakya orthodoxy by writing a sharp critique of Sakya Pandita’s A Thorough Differentiation of the Three Vows, posing more than 100 questions to Sakya scholars. He answered many of these questions in his later work, the Golden Lancet, which sparked controversy.

In Definite Ascertainment of the Middle Way he argued that Tsongkhapa’s Madhyamaka was too focused on logical analysis and still clung to concepts about an ultimate reality that is beyond language.

In his later years, Chokden moved away from a strict Prasangika Madhyamika view and embraced a Shentong approach influenced by Asanga, Vasubandhu, and Maitreya-nātha. He sought to reconcile Yogacara and Madhyamaka as valid, complementary paths to Ultimate Truth.

Chokden argued that Yogacara’s Alikakaravada (the idea that mental objects are ultimately unreal) can be understood in a way that fits with Madhyamaka’s emptiness. He believed the same ultimate reality could be described from two compatible angles, a view he saw as especially suitable for Vajrayana practice.

One of his most controversial ideas was that Ultimate Reality or Primordial Mind is impermanent, a claim he linked to Yogacara as well as sutras and tantras. This conflicted with Sakya Pandita, and his writings were not well received in the Sakya school.

In the 1600s, followers of the Gelug school banned his writings and shut down the printer that kept them.