On a Pale Horse

Content sourced from Wikipedia, licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

On a Pale Horse is a fantasy novel by Piers Anthony, first published in 1983. It’s the first book in the Incarnations of Immortality series.

The story follows Zane, a penniless photographer who intends to kill himself. As he’s about to pull the trigger, Death appears and is killed by Zane. Fate explains that whoever kills Death must take Death’s place, so Zane becomes the new Death. His pale horse (Mortis) can take other forms, like a boat, a plane, or a limousine, and he must learn to use Death’s powers.

Guided by Chronos, the Incarnation of Time, Zane learns his duties: he must gather the souls of people who are on the cusp between Heaven and Hell and help decide their fates. He soon discovers his appointment wasn’t accidental. A powerful magician, Cedric Kaftan Jr., has manipulated events for his own purposes, and the magician’s daughter, Luna Kaftan, is tied to a prophecy about stopping Satan, the Incarnation of Evil.

The magician hopes to guide Zane into falling in love with Luna to protect her. To balance her soul, the magician uses dark magic that burdens Luna with evil. Luna volunteers to swap places with another dying client to balance her own soul, hoping to do good. But Satan’s schemes continue, and Zane — who has fallen for Luna — refuses to take her soul.

The other four Incarnations — Time, Fate, War, and Nature — reveal they were all part of a larger plan to place a mortal in Death’s seat. Satan tries to force Zane to quit his strike, but Zane learns from Gaia, the Incarnation of Nature, that each Incarnation holds real power within its realm. He realizes that Death’s office cannot be overridden by Satan. The confrontation ends in a draw, and Luna’s destiny is altered so she is saved. Zane lifts his strike, and with Luna protected, Satan can no longer interfere with her fate.

Reception notes: Dave Langford praised the book for treating life-and-death matters with serious, inventive mechanics of magic and the afterlife, calling it entertaining and fresh. Richard Mathews highlighted how the novel uses Death and the other Incarnations to explore abstract ideas in a way that helps readers grapple with mortality.